What’s the Fuss About Michael and Debi Pearl?
Posted by TulipGirl | Under Pearls / TTUAC / NGJ Friday Mar 31, 2006You may (or may not) have seen the call to boycott Homeschool Blogger/The Old Schoolhouse because of their ongoing, outspoken support for Michael and Debi Pearl’s materials, specificly their extra-biblical parenting teachings. This attention is a result of a little boy who died at the hands of his mother. The mother had sought guidance from the Pearls’ materials.
For quick reference, here are some articles that may illustrate the grave concerns people have about what Michael and Debi Pearl teach.
Here at TulipGirl:
On the Pearls and Parenting
Pearls Po-Russki
Biblical Relationships or Behaviourism
Children, Good and Grown
Offsite:
Authoritarianism and Isolationism Among Us (small type, worth the effort of reading)
The Pearls: The Basics, On Original Sin
To Train Up A Child Review
TTUAC: One Family’s Experiences
Chapter-by-Chapter Review of TTUAC
Avoiding Millstones
TTUAC Short Review
Other Related Blog Posts:
An Alternative to HSB
Click-and-Go Boycott Guide
I’m Okay, You’re Okay
Enough
Tulip, I agree with the overall premise of your post entitled, “Biblical Relationships or Behaviourism.” However, I am still unclear about whether, or not, this approach precludes the use of the rod (ie. wooded spoon) in cases of deliberate disobedience. What are your thoughts about that?
By the way, I am definitely more in line with “Shepherding a Child’s Heart” in antithesis to “Growing Kids God’s Way” and other similar programs that use both Ivan Pavlov and B.F. Skinner type methodology.
“I am definitely more in line with “Shepherding a Child’s Heart” in antithesis to “Growing Kids God’s Way” and other similar programs that use both Ivan Pavlov and B.F. Skinner type methodology.”
If I remember correctly, it was some well-placed and gentle words from your wife that helped me realize, “Hey, this Ezzo guy has some serious theological errors–at least serious theological sloppiness!”
I find some of what is in SACH to be inspiring. I find some of it goes beyond what the Bible teaches.
I do believe discipline, correction, reproof, chastisement–all of those are mandated in Scripture. I don’t believe that the Bible mandates smacking a small child on the backside with a hand/implement. While I don’t believe the Bible forbids spanking, I do see within the current Christian subculture extra-biblical teachings on spanking, some of which are downright disturbing. Obviously, the Pearls and their behaviouristic training-not-disicpline approach, but also the development of a theology of spanking that views it as a “means of grace.”
I have found that the Gospel can be communicated, good morals imparted, and Biblical discipline administered without the use of the rod/spanking. While my children are still a work in progress, I know many Christian mothers with grown children who didn’t rely upon spanking. And I know others who state they should not have spanked the way they did.
That said, God has placed our children in our families for a purpose. Each of us are responsible before Him for their training and nurturing in the Lord.
To spank or not to spank–that really isn’t the question.
Rather, am I integrating the Gospel in all areas of life, including my relationship with my children?
Am I walking in the Spirit, bearing the Fruit of the Spirit, and is the reflected in how I treat my husband and children?
Am I relying upon the Holy Spirit or a method with my children?
Am I faithfully instructing them in the Word, catechizing them, teaching them?
Am I leaning into the Lord and seeking grace when I struggle? Am I extending that same grace to my children?
Am I relating to my children as brothers in the Lord?
I find that the issue of spanking fades to the background when I’m focusing on these things instead.
I hope this is helpful, Barry. You know I think very highly of y’all–and would not want you to hear condemnation from me.
Grace and peace,
I tried to do a trackback to you – but I can’t get it to work on my site. Anyway, you always do a great job with summarizing and gathering resources. I appreciate you.
Thanks for the link to homeschooljournal.
Thanks for these…I actually just read the article on equip.org earlier this morning. It was quite good. I particularly appreciate your questions in your comment regarding our own walk with Christ.
Could you tell me where to find Michael Pearl’s reference to the plumbing line? I am thinking it is not in TTUAC.
TIA
Tulip-girl, as always your posts are thoughtful and well stated. I’ve been following your comments other places as well, and think you’re doing a wonderful job of presenting this side of the argument. People need to know that what the Pearls teach is dangerous and irresponsible.
Annette,
It is in this article on the NGJ website:
The full quote, so people can see it is not being taken out of context:
What instrument would I use?
As a rule, do not use your hand. Hands are for loving and helping. If an adult swings his or her hand fast enough to cause pain to the surface of the skin, there is a danger of damaging bones and joints. The most painful nerves are just under the surface of the skin. A swift swat with a light, flexible instrument will sting without bruising or causing internal damage. Many people are using a section of ¼ inch plumber’s supply line as a spanking instrument. It will fit in your purse or hang around you neck. You can buy them for under $1.00 at Home Depot or any hardware store. They come cheaper by the dozen and can be widely distributed in every room and vehicle. Just the high profile of their accessibility keeps the kids in line.
Annette, the instructions on “spanking” in TTUAC include, but are not limited to:
“Use your own judgment as to what is effective. I found five to ten licks usually sufficient. . . .A general rule is to continue the disciplinary action until the child is surrendered. . . .
.
“Make it a point never to use your hand for spanking. . . .
“. . .The hand on a diapered bottom is useless as a spanking, but effective in causing permanent damage to the spine. There is no surface pain to the child thus whipped. Any pain would be deep inside, similar to a fall or a car wreck. Any spanking, to effectively reinforce instruction, must cause pain, but the most pain is on the surface of bare skin where the nerves are located. A surface sting will cause sufficient pain, with no injury or bruising. Select your instrument according to the child’s size. For the under one year old, a little, ten- to twelve-inch long, willowy branch (striped of any knots that might break the skin) about one-eighth inch diameter is sufficient. Sometimes alternatives have to be sought. A one-foot ruler, or its equivalent in a paddle, is a sufficient alternative. For the larger child, a belt or larger tree branch is effective.
Please note: I will not link to the text of TTUAC. While I believe adults are free to read what they will and I am not “censoring” TTUAC, I will not promote it by linking to it.
It is a horrible thing in our day. We choose to whip or spank kids so they obey. God is not spanking us, as adults, but people reject common sense. I was spanked as a child. Do I remember the offense??? NO..I remember how traumitized I was and began counting the days till I would graduate-from when I was in 6th grade…I have NO contact with my parents and would NOT subject my precious children to that type of “punishment” or “biblical parenting discipline” I am a christian and children’s author and pray that our country does indeed move forward with the NO-Spanking laws so people are forced to use their brain not their hand or another object…God gave us brains to use not just hands..Children are a gift from God..the Bible states..So is this how you take care of your gifts????
FYI-Christmas and Easter are NOT christian holidays and yet because people put Christ into them, they celebrate them and okay it…You cant justify one without the other…Praying your kids will see the love of Christ in people who show grace as Christ does for us. Hannah, children’s author and speaker..
[...] What’s the Fuss About Michael and Debi Pearl? [...]
You stated that the issue is not spanking in a blog above; “To spank or not to spank–that really isn’t the question.” but yet so much of your focus is on dismanteling the No Greater Joy organization that is portraying thier conviction on childrearing regarding the spanking issue. Tulip girl, you might be better suited to not judge your chirstian neighbor and let God judge them if they are in error. I have found it detrimental to the Body of Christ when factions occur and back biting is done regarding biblical interpretataions.
I’m the other Jen
No Greater Joy has helped a lot of people. Some people have huge anger problems that they need to repent of. That is where you have the problems, when people don’t train their children properly and use the rod in love. Not anger. By the way, you are taking away the freedoms that our fore fathers fought for by all this negativity.
In their child-rearing books, the message that I received is that …yes, you control with the rod(as written in scripture) but your attitude and spirit during that time is LOVE and NOT harsh or cruel. If beating your child is the only message you got from the Pearls book…it is failure on your part to comprehend the message. I believe the Pearls are doing a wonderful job to preserve our families for God
Jen (the first, *grin*),
Honestly, spanking or not spanking is NOT the issue. The issue IS, as in the comment above, how do we live out the Gospel in our family relationships?
I have never focused on “dismantling” NGJ. In fact, I’ve mentioned the Pearls relatively infrequently here. . . In about 1500 posts over 4+ years, I’ve blogged on the Pearls about a dozen times. A few of those times were even reposts!
As a Christian, it is my responsibility before the Lord to examine the teachings I hear, from whatever source. Shouldn’t we be doing that with all teachings? Holding them up to the light of Scripture and judging whether they are consistent with God’s revealed truth in the Bible?
As I have shared (and I encourage you to peruse the links in the opening post) I have serious concerns about their teachings, both theologically and practically.
This isn’t an issue of “backbiting” or “factions” or even spanking. . . this IS an issue of encouraging one another to be true to the Gospel of Jesus Christ and being careful in our study of Scripture.
Jen (the other one!)
Questioning the veracity of one man’s teaching is in no way “taking away the freedoms that our fore fathers fought for. . .”
(Though, I am aware that NGJ did use the fear tactic of “taking away freedoms” when they encouraged people to comment here and on other sites.)
I find it interesting that you bring up the how some people have “anger issues.” Others have alcohol issues. Or were abused in the past. You are right that sins from our past (or present) can make parents more vulnerable in crossing the line from discipline to abuse. Personally, I believe that the Pearls and all parents who advocate their parenting materials would be wise to read this article on Avoiding Millstones.
Hello, Connie!
I’m really glad that you mention the “overzealous spanking mother” who needs to gain control over herself.
How can a loving, well-intentioned mother recognize when she is being “overzealous”?
I think that you would be encouraged by what Ann @ Holy Experience shares about what the Lord has done in her life related to that.
Angela, I’d invite you to join the discussion over here, which touches closely on the comment you made.
Connie, welcome to the discussion here! It’s been pretty lively on some threads.
Can you explain why it is ok for you to criticize Tulipgirl but not ok for her to critique the Pearls’ teachings?
It seems like you are doing to Tulipgirl the very thing you don’t want HER to do.
In actual fact, Scripture teaches us to reason together, and to examine teachings that come along to see if they are true. We are to reject teachings that do not comport with the gospel of Christ.
A. W. Tozer wrote some encouragement about this:
“Many tender-minded Christians fear to sin against love by daring to inquire into anything that comes wearing the cloak of Christianity and breathing the name of Jesus. They dare not examine the credentials of the latest prophet to hit their town lest they be guilty of rejecting something which may be of God. They timidly remember how the Pharisees refused to accept Christ when He came, and they do not want to be caught in the same snare, so they either reserve judgment or shut their eyes and accept everything without question. This is supposed to indicate a high degree of spirituality. But in sober fact it indicates no such thing. It may indeed be evidence of the absence of the Holy Spirit.
Gullibility is not synonymous with spirituality. Faith is not a mental habit leading its possessor to open his mouth and swallow everything that has about it the color of the supernatural. Faith keeps its heart open to whatever is of God, and rejects everything that is not of God, however wonderful it may be. Try the spirits is a command of the Holy Spirit to the Church. We may sin as certainly by approving the spurious as by rejecting the genuine. And the current habit of refusing to take sides is not the way to avoid the question. To appraise things with a heart of love and then to act on the results is an obligation resting upon every Christian in the world. And the more as we see the day approaching.”
Yes, this does sometimes put good and faithful Christians at odds. But we can reason together in a way that is not harsh and does not tear one another down. What we can’t do–mustn’t do, is feel that something is quite wrong, and say nothing.
[...] Joy Magazine July/August 2008 issue published by Michael and Debi Pearl. All those new visitors who have commented on various threads so far will be entered into the drawing — and those who comment [...]
[...] What’s the Fuss About Michael and Debi Pearl? [...]
Helpful information. Thank you! I’ve linked to you here, http://www.timberdoodlecompany.com/doodleblog/2010/02/17/discipline-and-murder/
[...] A thoughtful critique from Tulipgirl, written in 2006 but still quite relevant, and with links to useful resources. Her reaction to the latest tragedy is here. [...]
I want to mention something regarding biblical bible quotes.
The Old Testament’s statement that if “you beat them with a rod, they will not die. Proverbs 23:13 is wrong.
Countless children have died. Jesus went against many of the Old Testament teachings.That is a fact.
A PBS speaker on family dysfunction pointed out that King Soloman wrote the quotes that support physically assaulting children.
King Soloman and his son heavily taxed their kingdom and was otherwise brutal.Was that based on God’s teachings?son he was ousted. Who have him the right to have power over the people?
Here is a quote by Rehoboam.
“Whereas my father laid upon you a heavy yoke, so shall I add tenfold thereto. Whereas my father chastised (tortured) you with whips, so shall I chastise you with scorpions. For my littlest finger is thicker than my father’s loins; and your backs, which bent like reeds at my father’s touch, shall break like straws at my own touch.”
So, people are following the teachings of brutal leaders not God or Jesus.
It is a very good point!
Interesting read, perhaps the best article iv’e browse today. We learn everyday cheers to you!
Hiya guys, I spottet a great way to make a lot of money online blogging. I suppose this is most likely for the website bloggers but there are probably more bloggers reading this. I have made thousands using the techniques explained in the product and it’s only been 2 months. Free Money Making Blog By Blogging To The Bank
Why did you remove my post… My post was actually useful unlike most of these comments. Ill post it again. Hey , I have been using a great way to make alot of money online making blogs. I presume this is most likely for the website administrator but there are probably more bloggers reading this. I have made thousands using the techniques detailed in the product and it has only been two months. Free Money Making Blog By Blogging To The Bank
I’ve already downloaded it, it is very nice to use
I really love wine. I remember the first time I tried some when I was just 12 years old. My mom let me taste a bit of her blush on Thankgiving. Right then and there I became a wine drinker. lol I would guess that I have tried quite a few hundred different wines over the years. It’s kind of fun experiencing a new one and learning about how and where it was grown. I’ve been thinking about joining a wine club lately and I’ve been thinking about this 4 Seasons club. I read a review about it on this site. Have you had any experience with it, or would you recommend any other wine tasting club?
I was looking looking for momentous gen on this subject. The communication was important as I am thither to set in motion my own portal. Thanks for providing a missing relate in my business.
When I first graduated a few years ago I had to work for a lot less than I thought I would have to. My advice to anyone just out of law school is to get your foot in the door and worry about the money a few years in the future.
I really loved this post. You write about this topic very well. I really like your blog and I will definetly bookmark it! Keep up the great posts!
I have to agree with butch883 and hope everybody reads those comments
blog bookmarked and stumbled upon, I¡¯ll post a feedback on my site asap
Thanks a lot for the blog article.Really looking forward to read more. Fantastic.
Wonderful blog! I really love how it’s easy on my eyes as well as the data are well written. I am wondering how I might be notified whenever a new post has been made. I have subscribed to your rss feed which should do the trick! Have a nice day!
Hoeveel kan ik lenen? (hypotheek). Wat worden mijn maandlasten? (hypotheek) … Hoeveel hypotheek heb ik nodig? Hoe hoog is de boete die ik nu zou moeten
I like the writing theme of your site and it does a pretty decent job of presenting the information.
You have a fantastic blog here, really informative. Very well written I shall be bookmarking the website and subscribing to your feed so i can always read content of this quality.
BKR problemen? Nu Geld lenen zonder BKR toetsing? Op zoek naar betrouwbare aanbieders? Wij vergelijken banken die u toch kunnen helpen aan een betrouwbare
I like the writing structure of your site and it does a pretty good job of presenting the info.
Great I have read your article and by the way I found you website on Google and I think after I read several post on you website especially this one I have my own comment about what should I say on the next meeting with my family, maybe tomorrow I will tell my girl friendabout this one and get debate.
That is very sublime stuff. Never new that beliefs could be this varied. Thanks for all the enthusiasm to extend such helpful information at this site.
Just gonna commentabout this article, after reading whole of this it make me to have new vision about one important event, hope I can read more quality news again from you so I bookmark your website.
Men have a tendency to buy you what they want you to have and not what you want. I have this happen to me every birthday, christmas, and anniversary. I just keep the present and go out and buy myself what I really want. It saves us both from being mad and resentful
Great post and website! I have bookmarked it and will check back ofter. I also linked you to my site.
Recently after upgrading to GEN D3, I have been faced with an annoying (but not critical) bug were the X and O buttons swap. On the XMB it is normal where X is to confirm and O is to cancel, but as soon as the game launches, they swap and I don’t know why.
wrap a couple rubber bands around your toothbrush right where you rest your fingers so that you’ll notice it when you pick it up. that’ll help you remember to put them in after you brush your teeth!
some times I wear a full face respirator for work – I always put a drop of dawn dish soap inside and rub it with a paper towel until it’s clear wear I can see – always worked for me – been over 15 years
Wonderful blog! I truly love how it’s uncomplicated on my eyes and the details is well written. I am wondering how I can be notified whenever a new post has been made. I have subscribed to your rss feed which should do the trick! Have a nice day!Also welcome to my website.-gucci handbags
Need to subscribe to this blog, great post. Found it on bing.
Which Sansa do you have? I have a Sansa. You should have a USB cord that connects to your Mp3 Player to the USB port on your computer. You just have to make sure it’s in the MP3 Player and the other end is in the computer. You might get a pop-up that says "What do you want to do?", if not, go to "e:/" and you can drag and drop songs from the folder onto there. This is how I get songs onto mine. Good luck.
I try to gear the gift, both in presentation and utility, to the recipient. A hand drawn/painted portrait of a mother’s child is almost always a sure winner. Handmade photograph albums are pretty easy to do, as far as books go, and allow for much thematic creativity. Making an herb/spice collection for a cook is another idea. Teenagers can be rough to make things for, in my experience, so, if I have to do something for that age group, I try for unusual. Marionettes, pocket journals, wallets, and the like. My in laws are not overly fond of the hand made gifts, at least if it’s not handmade by a known, signed artist. So I don’t waste my time and energy on them. I just get a gift certificate for whatever I would’ve spent to make something.
hey I really liked your blog and the posts. I will bookmark this site and return.
When I was trying to lose weight after my third child, I used Acai Ultra Burn and lost over 40 lbs. I’ve been able to keep all that weight off for over 6 months.
Hey could I quote some of the material found in this post if I link back to you?
I’m pretty sure that most of travel agents salary is based off of how much they sell to customers, sort of like a commission of the cost of the trip. (This might also be based on various companies procedure, so don’t base it all off of this answer)
I really like your site. Very good posts! Please continue posting such awesome cotent.
Saved your site. Appreciation for discussing. Surely well worth time clear of my personal tests.
That is very sublime stuff. Never new that beliefs could be this varied. Thanks for all the enthusiasm to extend such helpful information at this site.
There are amny books available online foe SEO purpose, you cannot say which one is best or not. It all depends on the person how he understands the concepts and theories. You can also go to other SEO books like "Road 2 SEO by Tony Tateossian". It is also a great book to learn.
good articles here hopefully i learned from it.
optimization for social media is part of SEO, so there is no particular answer to your question. You can use social media for driving traffic to your page. As many people see the link it`s more likely that they will click and visit.
i know!!! The media is trying to grow kids up fast so that the industry has a wider range of buyers for their products. The thing is, transformers was originally an animated kids show, and then an animated movie, until the real life re-make where Shia La Boef and Megan Fox sex things up just a little too much, and use language that they probably shouldnt. Its all part of the Mega plan to get kids to whine to their parents to buy them everything. I know where you are coming from.
I support this post landlord
Great! It is just the software I am seeing for!
torrentz.com is usually a good search for all things including bollywood films. Most of the time though you can type the name of the film followed by ‘movie torrent’ in Google and get a download link.
I have the Garmin Nuvi 350. Its good. I like Garmin over Tom Tom because Garmin actually tells you the street names of where to turn, so instead of "in 800ft turn right" the Garmin will say "turn right on main street"
Great post and website! I have bookmarked it and will check back ofter. I also linked you to my site.
Who would have thought about this.
i found verygood info there good hope.
Can you introduce it in detail?
I don’t believe this! Smile
Search engines look for specific elements that are known to bring emphasis in web pages, like h[1-6], b, strong, and em. They skip over containers like span and div to get to the actual content.
tell your dad to put it under his name and that he is the primary driver and that you are the secondary driver.. this will make ur insurance a lot cheaper.. Good Luck!
I spent some time in your blog and discovered a lot of helpful posts. I’m impressed with the way you present your perspectives and ideas. I have added you to my firefox bookmarks and will come back for updates regularly. Thanks!
I don’t often agree with the comments that are given on sites but in this case I agree.
I’ve never wore makeup my skin is beautiful, soap & water, that is what I use, god gave me beautiful skin, why would I want to cover it up.Rediculious. But I understand some people have problem skin, I’m just glad they have something to help to help them. Hope you are having a great day.
On mine, I went into the Settings menu and changed the USB connection type to MSC. This makes it mount up like a USB drive when you plug it in, and you get a window with folders, including a folder called Music, which you can then copy mp3s into; just like moving files around in and out of any ordinary folder on your computer.
I commonly really don’t submit in Information sites but your weblog forced me to, amazing function.. gorgeous …
Well, you can find Free Demos on http://www.pspdemocenter.com. Go to the demo you wish, and connect your Usb cord to your computer and psp, a screen should pop up, select psp, now put the window to the side for a bit and download the demo of your choosing. Then when its done, drag the demo file into your game file. And when you go into your saved game data, the demo should be there. (Your psp has to be in Usb mode for this, And you can only download a demo that’s equal too or less than your memory card size.)
I have the garmin also… Everytime I turn it on it says searching for satellites, and it takes a whlie (like 7 mins) for it to find them, but after that it works perfect. If yours just says searching for sattelites, I would take it back and get a new one…. Maybe its a defect?
Amazing webpage and cheers for creating this post. I’m a day by day reader and I suspected you have to know that you’re a highly beneficial writer.
It’s tricky for me to keep reading this post mainly because there are scattered graphics throughout the story.
How come newcomers criticize this?
You are making several good points during this posting however its very hard for me personally to concentrate on this content on the complicated page design!
Wonderful blog! I actually love how it’s easy on my eyes and also the data are well written. I am wondering how I can be notified whenever a new post has been made. I have subscribed to your rss feed which really should do the trick! Have a nice day!